| Date | Time | Event | | Score | Record | |
|---|
| 12-14-99 | 8:00 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 01-15-00 | 8:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 11-30-01 | 6:15 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | N |
| 01-12-02 | 6:15 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 12-06-02 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 35-31 | 1-0 | L |
| 12-27-02 | 6:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | | 1-0 | | T |
| 01-18-03 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 71-58 | 2-0 | L |
| 12-05-03 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 56-48 | 3-0 | N |
| 01-17-04 | 7:45 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 50-40 | 4-0 | L |
| 12-03-04 | 7:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 57-40 | 5-0 | L |
| 01-15-05 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 47-44 | 5-1 | L |
| 03-04-05 | 7:30 pm | vs Mount Vernon, Illinois at Salem, Illinois | W | 56-26 | 6-1 | P |
| 12-23-05 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 57-38 | 7-1 | L |
| 01-14-06 | 6:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 56-46 | 8-1 | L |
| 12-22-06 | 7:45 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 44-33 | 9-1 | L |
| 01-13-07 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 33-31 | 10-1 | L |
| 11-28-08 | 6:00 pm | vs Mount Vernon, Illinois at Alton | | | | T |
| 12-03-10 | 7:45 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 56-42 | 10-2 | L |
| 01-28-11 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 43-39 | 10-3 | L |
| 02-28-12 | 6:00 pm | vs Mount Vernon, Illinois at Marion | L | 47-26 | 10-4 | T |
| 01-11-13 | 7:45 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 64-54 | 10-5 | L |
| 02-22-13 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 01-10-14 | 6:15 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 02-21-14 | 6:15 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 03-10-15 | 7:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 71-53 | 11-5 | T |
| 12-18-15 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 49-33 | 11-6 | L |
| 02-12-16 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 61-55 | 11-7 | L |
| 12-16-16 | 7:45 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 49-27 | 12-7 | L |
| 02-10-17 | 7:45 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 46-32 | 13-7 | L |
| 12-08-17 | 6:15 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 55-39 | 14-7 | L |
| 02-02-18 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 58-51 | 15-7 | L |
| 12-07-18 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 57-38 | 15-8 | L |
| 02-01-19 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 40-28 | 16-8 | L |
| 12-06-19 | 6:15 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | W | 54-39 | 17-8 | L |
| 01-31-20 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 66-63 | 17-9 | L |
| 02-05-21 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 58-24 | 17-10 | L |
| 02-26-21 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 63-33 | 17-11 | L |
| 12-03-21 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 56-45 | 17-12 | L |
| 01-14-22 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 54-46 | 17-13 | L |
| 01-06-23 | 6:00 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 51-38 | 17-14 | L |
| 01-20-23 | 6:30 pm | vs Mount Vernon, Illinois at Salem, Illinois | L | 50-40 | 17-15 | T |
| 02-15-23 | 7:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 01-05-24 | 7:30 pm | at Mount Vernon, Illinois | | | | L |
| 02-17-24 | 2:30 pm | Mount Vernon, Illinois | L | 53-48 | 17-16 | L |